American Idol - Top 8 - David Cook - "Innocent"

Randy: Yo baby, check it out, Im a huge fan, not sure it was one of your strongest weaks.
Paula: You are so well defined as being the whole package.
Simon: Didn't like this performance at all, a little pompous. Weakest performance.
Me: I think it was risky not a very well known song. By me at least.