American Idol - Top 8 - Carly Smithson -- "The Show Must Go On"

Randy: Started out good, got a little pitchy, just ok for me.
Paula: I didn't feel engaged with you, voice sounded amazing
Simon: You look good. An unusual choice for you, you lost control of the song. It came across as angry which goes against the theme for tonight.
Me: Love this song. Really didn't care for this. It did seem angry. Carly always seems angry to me.