American Idol - Top 7 - Carly Smithson -- "Without You"

Randy: Yo, I liked that you challenged yourself with this song; you have to believe in yourself and use your lower range too!
Paula: I actually liked that you showed some vocal restraint; you made it your own.
Simon: I really wanted to see you sing this song even before Mariah Carey week. So, here we are, and did it work. And, I don't think it did. It was ok, but you can do better, you have to believe in yourself and stop over thinking everything.
Me: It was pretty good, she just is constantly scrunching up her face. She has zero connection with the audience.